What is topping off your wine?
Whether it is a cork or screw cap, you can discuss the benefits and disadvantages of each, but it all comes down to a matter of your taste. What does the wine taste like? What closures gives you the best expression of the wine? What closure lets you taste the wine as the winemaker intended? These are the questions that matter.
Find a closure you are behind, that you love and appreciate. Maybe you want a screw cap when you are in a hurry, or you like the idea of a cork coming out of a bottle and making its distinctive sound....it is what your like and not about history or tradition. What gives you the personnal taste you deserve.